Internal vs. External Audits: Why Taking Control Matters

by Natalie Glancy | July 29, 2026

Every organization will be audited at some point.  The real question is how.

Will it be:

  • An internal review you control
    or
  • An external audit you have to respond to?

That distinction matters more than most teams realize.

What an External Audit Looks Like

External audits are initiated by payers or third parties.

They’re typically:

  • Triggered by patterns in your data
  • Focused on specific services or providers
  • Time-sensitive and documentation-heavy

By the time they begin:

  • The scope is already defined
  • The concerns are already identified
  • The burden is on you to respond

You’re reacting, not preparing.

What an Internal Audit Changes

An internal audit flips that dynamic.

Instead of responding to outside questions, you’re asking your own:

  • Where are we inconsistent?
  • What patterns are emerging?
  • Are we aligned with payer expectations?

This allows you to:

  • Identify issues early
  • Correct them proactively
  • Strengthen processes before they’re tested externally

Can an Internal Audit Be Performed by a Third Party?

Absolutely.  Many organizations choose to work with an independent third party, like AMS, to perform internal audits because they provide objectivity, specialized expertise, and an outside perspective that internal teams may not have.

The key distinction isn't who performs the audit, it's who initiates it and who controls the process.

A proactive audit, whether conducted by your own staff or by a trusted partner, is still considered an internal review because:

  • Your organization defines the scope and objectives.
  • The findings are used to improve processes, not impose penalties.
  • You decide how and when to address identified issues.
  • The goal is prevention and performance improvement.

An external audit, on the other hand, is initiated by a payer or regulatory agency, where the concerns and scope have already been determined for you.

The advantage of an independent third-party audit is that it gives you the benefit of objective expertise while allowing you to remain in control of the process.

Why This Difference Is Critical

External audits often lead to:

  • Recoupments
  • Increased scrutiny
  • Ongoing monitoring

Internal audits lead to:

  • Better visibility
  • Stronger processes
  • More confidence in your data

Same concept. Very different outcomes.

Control the Process, Not Just the Response

Waiting for an external audit puts you in a defensive position.

A proactive audit puts you in control.

At AMS, we work with organizations to:

  • Identify risks early
  • Validate documentation and coding
  • Provide clear, actionable recommendations

So if an external audit does occur, you’re prepared, not reacting.

👉 Schedule a Revenue Cycle Audit Consultation with AMS
👉 Or take a proactive step with a controlled internal review


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between an internal audit and an external audit?

An internal audit is initiated by the healthcare organization and is designed to identify opportunities for improvement before issues escalate. An external audit is initiated by a payer or regulatory agency and focuses on reviewing specific concerns or billing patterns.

Can a third party perform an internal audit?

Yes. Many healthcare organizations hire independent third-party experts to conduct internal audits. The audit is still considered an internal review because the organization controls the scope, timing, and use of the findings.

Why should healthcare organizations conduct internal audits?

Internal audits help identify coding inconsistencies, documentation gaps, workflow issues, and compliance risks before they result in denials, payer scrutiny, or recoupments. They also provide actionable recommendations to improve performance.

What are examples of external audits in healthcare?

Examples of external audits include:

Medicare audits
Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) audits
Unified Program Integrity Contractor (UPIC) audits
Commercial payer audits
Medicaid integrity reviews
Office of Inspector General (OIG) audits

Are internal audits required in healthcare?

While not all organizations are required to perform formal internal audits, regular reviews are considered a best practice and are recommended as part of an effective compliance program.

How often should a healthcare organization perform internal audits?

The frequency depends on the organization's size and complexity, but many practices benefit from annual audits or targeted reviews when there are changes in providers, increasing denials, or emerging compliance concerns.

Can internal audits help prevent external audits?

Internal audits cannot guarantee that an external audit will never occur, but they can help organizations identify and address issues early, reducing risk and improving preparedness if a payer or regulatory review takes place.

What are the benefits of using a third-party audit firm?

Independent auditors provide objective insights, specialized expertise, and an unbiased perspective. They can identify trends and risks that may be overlooked internally and provide recommendations to strengthen processes and compliance.

What does a healthcare revenue cycle audit evaluate?

A revenue cycle audit may review:

Patient registration and front-end processes
Documentation and coding practices
Denial trends
Billing workflows
Accounts receivable processes
Compliance risks
Opportunities for operational improvement

How can AMS help with internal audits?

AMS provides independent revenue cycle audits designed to help healthcare organizations identify process gaps, improve documentation and coding consistency, reduce compliance risk, and strengthen overall financial performance. Our goal is to provide practical, actionable recommendations that help organizations stay ahead of potential issues.

1