In-House vs Outsourced Medical Billing: Which Saves More?

by Applied Medical Systems

For small practices, managing medical billing efficiently can make or break your revenue cycle. Choosing between in-house billing and outsourcing isn't just a financial decision—it impacts staff productivity, patient experience, and compliance. In this guide, we'll break down the costs, both visible and hidden, to help your practice make an informed choice.

Why This Decision Matters

The method you choose for medical billing affects your revenue cycle health in major ways. A misstep can lead to delayed payments, increased denials, and unnecessary administrative headaches.

  • Common misconceptions: Many practices believe outsourcing is too expensive, while others feel in-house gives more control.
  • Small practices feel the pain more acutely: Limited staff, tight budgets, and less room for error make billing decisions critical.

Breaking Down In-House Billing Costs

Running an in-house billing team requires more than just hiring a staff member. Here’s what you need to consider:

  • Staff salaries & benefits: Billing specialists or coders can cost $45K–$60K annually each, plus health benefits, retirement contributions, and bonuses.
  • Ongoing training & certifications: HIPAA compliance, coding updates (CPT, ICD-10), and staff development programs.
  • Billing software licenses: Monthly or yearly costs for EMR integrations and billing platforms.
  • Office space, turnover, and productivity loss: Hiring, training, and employee turnover reduce efficiency.
  • Hidden costs: Denials, compliance risk, claim delays, and staff burnout.

The Real Cost of Outsourced Billing

Outsourced billing can seem like a “black box,” but it often provides more predictable costs and fewer surprises.

  • Typical fee: Most vendors charge 4–7% of collections, depending on volume and specialty.
  • Included services: Professional staff, advanced billing technology, compliance monitoring, and reporting.
  • Flexibility vs. fixed cost: Scale up or down without hiring, training, or infrastructure investments.

Side-by-Side Comparison (With Example Numbers)

Let’s consider a small practice submitting 500 claims per month, with an average reimbursement of $150 per claim:

  • In-house annual cost: $120K–$150K (staff, software, training, office overhead)
  • Outsourced annual cost: 4–7% of collections (~$36K–$63K/year)

Example Table:

Beyond Dollars — The “Soft Costs” to Consider

Not all costs show up in a spreadsheet. Here are some “soft costs” that can impact your decision:

  • Focus of physicians/admins: Time spent managing billing is time away from patient care or strategy.
  • Staff turnover headaches: Recruiting and training new billers drains resources.
  • Risk of compliance mistakes: Errors can lead to audits and penalties.
  • Patient experience impact: Billing delays and errors frustrate patients and harm satisfaction scores.

Hidden Benefits to Consider

Outsourcing doesn’t just save money, it gives your practice access to an entire team of experts, tools, and technology such as:

  • Access to Certified Coders: Most small practices don’t employ certified coders due to cost. Outsourcing provides credentialed experts who ensure accuracy, reduce denials, and keep claims compliant with the latest updates to CPT and ICD-10 standards.
  • Expert Reporting and Data Analysis:  Outsourced billing teams typically include specialists who analyze your financial reports, identify trends, and highlight areas for improvement - insights many in-house billers don’t have time or training to provide. 
  • Built-In IT Support and Security:  Billing companies invest heavily in secure technology infrastructure, system integrations, and data protection. You benefit from built-in IT assistance, HIPAA-compliant software, and automatic system updates—without needing to manage or troubleshoot those systems yourself.
  • Ability to Scale with Your Growth:  As your practice grows or adds new providers, your outsourced billing team can scale right alongside you—no hiring, onboarding, or additional software licenses required.
  • Guaranteed Coverage During Staff Absences:  No more workflow interruptions when your  staff is  out. Outsourcing ensures continuous claim submission and payment follow-up ensuring your cash flow never stops.
  • Compliance and Audit Readiness:  Outsourcing partners stay on top of evolving payer rules, CMS guidelines, and compliance regulations. They continuously monitor for red flags and documentation gaps, reducing the risk of costly audits or penalties.
  • Improved Patient Experience:  Accurate, timely billing reduces confusion and delays-improving patient satisfaction and trust in your practice.

Which is Right for You?

  • Outsourcing: Offers flexibility, scalability, and often cost savings.
  • In-house: Provides control and familiarity with internal workflows.
  • Decision depends on practice size, specialty, and growth stage.

Next Step

Not sure which path makes the most sense for your practice?

Schedule a free revenue consultation with Applied Medical Systems, and we’ll show you exactly how your billing model impacts your bottom line.

1